Looking To Sell or Trade A Toy? Get A Quote.


Got Something To Sell? Tell Us About It.

It seems everyone has old toys stashed away in an attic, basement, closet or even a storage unit.  If you think it’s time to move on, keep in mind that we are always buying new inventory. You may have something valuable that you don’t want to toss out during a move or spring-cleaning. Contact us and we will offer a fair and honest quote.


Our Honesty Policy

For over 25 years we have sold vintage and collectible toys spanning the 1930’s to last week. We understand the last thing you want is an over-graded, low quality toy that you don’t want in your collection. We don’t need the headaches any more than you do, which is why we grade on the conservative side and provide high resolution, unedited photos of the actual toy your are buying. We never use stock images.

Since we have a brick and mortar store you will never have a problem getting in touch with us. We provide our name, address and phone number right up front. We know how frustrating it is to purchase something on-line if you don’t believe you can talk directly to the seller.

Along these same lines, our Privacy Policy is straightforward: we do not share your information with any person, any company or any service at any time. It’s that simple. We strive to provide a worry-free online experience for our customers because the only way you’re going to come back and help to keep us in business is if you trust us.


Want To Sell A Toy? Get A Quote.

Fill out the form below to get a quote on a toy from your collection. All quotes are estimated until actually seen in person. This way we can see what you have, the condition and what you are looking to do with it.
  • Tell us something about the condition: How much play wear does it have? Is it complete? Does it work?
  • Drop files here or
    Pictures will help us get a good idea of what you have to sell.



  • Josh Magic: The Gathering Specialist

“The Toys Time Forgot is the coolest little shop around! They have some great toys, my childhood memories come flowing back every time I stop in. I wish I had all of my toys back, until I can buy them all its a great place to visit and dream, buying them back one by one.”

Get A Toy Quote

Building our collection for more than four decades, we have vintage toys from the 40’s, 50’s, 60’s and 70’s. Take a look at some of our older toys and see the tremendous variety we have in-stock.

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt